Sacrifice is the beginning of the process of meaning creation because it reveals to us what we value. In order for that to work, the sacrifice must be real. You must give up something that is of great value. You do that in service of something that is potentially of greater value. But the catch is that you can’t know in advance whether you will ever receive that value. That’s why a consumer transaction is never a sacrifice. It gives a fixed value for a fixed price. A sacrifice is more like an investment in a start-up company. You have to risk losing everything. You do it because you believe, not because you know.
Once upon a time, marriage required a genuine sacrifice because you could effectively never get divorced. The risk was that you would spend the rest of your life with someone you hated or you would marry somebody who would die young and leave you a widow(er). Of course, ultimately you can never know what is going to happen. That’s why life is sacred.
I agree! People have long equated status with entitlement, but the problem with this is it’s not creative at all. Heroic cultures generated a future through leading with sacrifice. It was considered something to honor, whereas in trader society leadership sacrifices others below them. The problem is conflating in group sacrifice for blanket sacrifice for all or for dysfunction even within the group.
Entitlement is the mentality of the nouveau riche who have not sacrificed anything and therefore didn’t earn their social position. It’s become dominant in the post-war years because almost the entire boomer generation was nouveau riche, especially in the US. The seeming paradox is that those who are given everything for free end up resenting their benefactors.
I agree but think it’s predates boomers, they more epitomize the end result. At a foundational level there has long been something amiss that folds into the next stage of the metazietgiest or age. The wording I chose could have been better… when I say entitlement I mean it not in a financial sense at all but the direction of sacrifice and efforts. Even before the boomers we had the concept of the fusion of the direction of sacrifice and status. Post Lycurgian Sparta (or even Lycurgus himself) would epitomize that status are those sacrificing the most, not the direction that sacrifice flows towards. Lycurgus would actually be a perfect example of extreme status because of his sacrifice, no entitlement. He would epitomize Progenic Hierarchy without actually having fathered any children. In their case, the entire ethnos functioned as a family unit. Like Fredrick the Great, Lycurgus would be a kind of father to the entire people.
Oh, absolutely. But the whole modern world is a rebellion against the Father!
The kings of Europe usually took the title of Pater Patriae (father of the fatherland). Meanwhile, the Pope is literally “papa”. Thus, there was a general rebellion against the Father beginning with the Reformation. The Dutch war against the Spanish, the British Civil War, the American, French and Russian revolutions were all wars against the archetypal Father by a society of archetypal Brothers (fraternité). But in a society of implied equals, any elevated status is invalid almost by definition.
Bellissimo articolo! Il sacrificio serve per dare una dimensione sacrale o per meglio dire divina all'esistenza degli esseri viventi. Senza sacrificio tutto si appiattisce, la vita diventa sterile.
Sacrifice is the beginning of the process of meaning creation because it reveals to us what we value. In order for that to work, the sacrifice must be real. You must give up something that is of great value. You do that in service of something that is potentially of greater value. But the catch is that you can’t know in advance whether you will ever receive that value. That’s why a consumer transaction is never a sacrifice. It gives a fixed value for a fixed price. A sacrifice is more like an investment in a start-up company. You have to risk losing everything. You do it because you believe, not because you know.
Once upon a time, marriage required a genuine sacrifice because you could effectively never get divorced. The risk was that you would spend the rest of your life with someone you hated or you would marry somebody who would die young and leave you a widow(er). Of course, ultimately you can never know what is going to happen. That’s why life is sacred.
I agree! People have long equated status with entitlement, but the problem with this is it’s not creative at all. Heroic cultures generated a future through leading with sacrifice. It was considered something to honor, whereas in trader society leadership sacrifices others below them. The problem is conflating in group sacrifice for blanket sacrifice for all or for dysfunction even within the group.
Entitlement is the mentality of the nouveau riche who have not sacrificed anything and therefore didn’t earn their social position. It’s become dominant in the post-war years because almost the entire boomer generation was nouveau riche, especially in the US. The seeming paradox is that those who are given everything for free end up resenting their benefactors.
I agree but think it’s predates boomers, they more epitomize the end result. At a foundational level there has long been something amiss that folds into the next stage of the metazietgiest or age. The wording I chose could have been better… when I say entitlement I mean it not in a financial sense at all but the direction of sacrifice and efforts. Even before the boomers we had the concept of the fusion of the direction of sacrifice and status. Post Lycurgian Sparta (or even Lycurgus himself) would epitomize that status are those sacrificing the most, not the direction that sacrifice flows towards. Lycurgus would actually be a perfect example of extreme status because of his sacrifice, no entitlement. He would epitomize Progenic Hierarchy without actually having fathered any children. In their case, the entire ethnos functioned as a family unit. Like Fredrick the Great, Lycurgus would be a kind of father to the entire people.
Oh, absolutely. But the whole modern world is a rebellion against the Father!
The kings of Europe usually took the title of Pater Patriae (father of the fatherland). Meanwhile, the Pope is literally “papa”. Thus, there was a general rebellion against the Father beginning with the Reformation. The Dutch war against the Spanish, the British Civil War, the American, French and Russian revolutions were all wars against the archetypal Father by a society of archetypal Brothers (fraternité). But in a society of implied equals, any elevated status is invalid almost by definition.
👏👏👏PHENOMENAL
Thank you! I appreciate feedback!
Bellissimo articolo! Il sacrificio serve per dare una dimensione sacrale o per meglio dire divina all'esistenza degli esseri viventi. Senza sacrificio tutto si appiattisce, la vita diventa sterile.
Grazie. L'esistenza si basa sul sacrificio.