Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Principality of Spirit's avatar

De Benoist makes a good point that if one considers that 33-34% of France is first to third generation Immigrant. Then the conclusion is that one cannot actually address any matter of this sort if it pertains to a third of France.

Even under le Gallou's point that the conversation is really about the 4 million foreign residents and the 7 million dual citizens, even assuming that the 3.1-3.2 million, that de Benoist identified and then le Gallou confirmed, are all part of that 11 million foreigner/dual citizen category, that still would leave a good 7 million of them still in France. And, beyond that, even with an explicit closed borders policy, which is clearly unrealistic as far as political will and ability go, society and the government has to then interact with these people somehow. They won't just go away nor will they just accept some subordinate role, they will continue to be part of France as anyone else is. That's, I think, Benoist's strongest argument here.

None of this even matters as much, because the problem in France continues to be that it has no grounds to differentiate who is a citizen and who is assimilated beyond some vague "loyalty to the republic". When France was a kingdom and Catholic, loyalty to the king and fidelity to the Church were legitimate categories of belonging, but France hasn't had a king or emperor to swear allegiance to since 1871 and it has not had a religion to belong to, even in a cultural sense, since 1905. French identity might as well be empty then unfortunately. This is why an assertive religion like Islam can get away with being so pernicious in French soil.

If anyone were to try the le Gallou solution of deporting people on the grounds of taking part in "anti-French/anti-France demonstrations", they wouldn't be able to prove this at court in any sense, because those people would show up and (earnestly or dishonestly) swear that they are French citizens, love France, love the republic and support laicite and French values, and nobody would be able to prove otherwise without a mind-reader.

Ready for more?