Discussion about this post

User's avatar
HamburgerToday's avatar

'Cite your source' is a rhetorical ploy. It's almost never requested by anyone who will accept the source when profferred.

The correct answer to 'cite your source' is 'No'.

The person seeking 'citation' is simply not ready to receive the information proffered no matter what form the answer is given.

If one is feeling less belligerant, then the proper response is 'What do you think having the citation would do for your understanding?'

Expand full comment
HamburgerToday's avatar

But I'm also opposed to the 'do your own research' time-waster as well.

99% of all disputes involve bad faith by one or both parties.

No amount of 'evidence' is ever going to change the other person's mind in such situations.

The purpose of public disputes is to beneficially affect the understanding of the audience, not your opponent.

The remaining 1% are usually due to magnifying trivial differences among persons who share at least 80% of the same beliefs.

If someone says 'Do research' my response is 'Make your own argument or get out of the conversation.'

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts